Why your revenue problem might not be a lead problem

Founders often attribute slow revenue growth to marketing problems, but business mentor and advisor Liv Hodge of Elite By Liv says they may be overlooking weak retention, poor onboarding and inconsistent delivery.

When revenue starts to slow, many business owners instinctively look for more customers through advertising and social media. But Liv Hodge, founder of Elite By Liv and a mentor and advisor to business owners, believes businesses need to look a little closer to home – that is, to examine what’s happening with the customers they already have.

“Acquisition is louder,” she says. “It’s the metric everyone talks about, it’s what the industry celebrates, and it’s the one that feels like progress. Retention is quieter. It’s happening in the background, and most founders don’t feel the pain of it until the bucket’s almost empty.”

Retention can be uncomfortable to look at because it forces founders to look inward. But for Liv, who has spent more than a decade building businesses across industries including hospitality, hairdressing, real estate and advertising, keeping the client you already have is significantly cheaper than acquiring a new one, and she says a business that retains well compounds.

Research by Bain & Company has long linked customer retention with profitability, finding that a 5% increase in retention can lift profits by 25% to 95%, depending on the industry.

“If leads are coming in but not converting, it’s a sales or offer problem, not a marketing one. If they’re converting but not staying, it’s a delivery or onboarding problem,” she says.

How retention is lost

In Liv’s experience, retention can be lost in three ways: weak onboarding, loss of perceived value over time and poor communication. Her job is to slow founders down long enough to work out where a break might be.

“The first question I ask is, ‘What’s happening with your existing clients right now?’ Because if the existing base is quiet, disengaged, or shrinking, no amount of new marketing will save you. You’d just be pouring fresh water into a leaking bucket.”

Liv encourages founders to look at metrics including customer lifetime value (how much a client is worth to your business over their time with you), churn rate (what percentage of clients are leaving in a given period), repeat purchase rate (how many clients are coming back after their first purchase), referral rates (a client who refers you to another) and engagement within the service or product.

“The overall theme is to stop measuring only what’s coming in, and to start measuring what’s staying. That’s where the health of the business really lives.”

Strong client retention looks like airtight onboarding with clear expectations, ongoing customer check-ins and caring about the small things.

For coaches, that could be check-in response rate and communication frequency, while for an e-commerce business, it could be email open rates and repeat visits. For service businesses, it could be how often existing clients are actively engaging with you.

Evidence supports the emphasis on onboarding: in a Wyzowl survey of 216 consumers, 86% said they would be more likely to remain loyal to a business that invested in content that welcomed and educated customers after purchase.

A higher bar for loyalty

But Liv says customer expectations have shifted considerably in recent years. PwC’s 2025 customer experience survey found that 29% of consumers stopped buying from a brand because of a poor customer experience, underscoring the cost of getting those interactions wrong.

Consumers now expect fast responses, personal experiences, hyper-relevant content, seamless delivery, and premium touchpoints as standard. The middle ground, Liv says, simply doesn’t exist: you are either delivering something exceptional, or becoming forgettable. Businesses that continue with a “set-and-forget” delivery system are at risk.

“That doesn’t mean retention is impossible; it means it has to be intentional. Businesses that treat retention as an active discipline are the ones thriving in the current market.”

And while AI can be a great tool to remove friction, it can be disastrous when it’s used to remove connection, she says. But her approach is simple: automate the admin while protecting the relationship.

“If the existing base is quiet, disengaged, or shrinking, no amount of new marketing will save you. You’d just be pouring fresh water into a leaking bucket.” – Liv

Her focus on retention stems from her own experience building businesses without external investment or paid acquisition in the early stages. She says those circumstances required her to focus on customer relationships, service, and referrals rather than relying on advertising to drive growth.

“It taught me that sustainable growth doesn’t come from spending more; it comes from serving better. Every dollar has to come from a real relationship, result, or referral. You can’t fake momentum with ad spend; you have to earn it.”

That philosophy now informs her work as a mentor and advisor through Elite By Liv, where she works directly with founders on crucial business touchpoints, such as offer structure, systems, marketing and operations. The practice is deliberately capacity-limited, allowing Liv to work directly with every client and, she says, engage more deeply with their businesses.

The biggest shift Liv helps founders make is realising that existing clients can be their growth strategy.

“Every business owner should build with the mindset that their next month’s revenue is being decided by how well they served last month’s clients,” she says.

Liv takes on a small number of clients personally. If that is the kind of work you are looking for, start here: elitebyliv.com.au

---

Want to see more Forbes articles on your feed? Tap here to make Forbes Australia a preferred source on Google.

Look back on the week that was with hand-picked articles from Australia and around the world. Sign up to the Forbes Australia newsletter here or become a member here.