Google on Tuesday said K-12 school districts that block its generative artificial intelligence tools will also lose the ability to use an AI-free version of Google Search, potentially cutting off access to the world’s most pervasive search engine for millions of students countrywide.
Key Facts
In a blog post, Google said it will automatically turn off the AI tools built into its popular software for K-12 students starting next year and will require administrations to opt in if they want students to be able to access Gemini products when using Google’s school hardware or software. The AI tools will remain inactive until school administrators explicitly toggle them on in their management console, but among those turned-off tools is access to the company’s basic search engine.
By lumping Google Search in with Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Gemini in Classroom, Google has created an “all-or-nothing” control setting that will force schools to embrace AI if they also want access to Search.
Chris Phillips, vice president for education at Google, told the New York Times that the company’s AI features are “deeply integrated” into search and students won’t have access to one without the other. In the same post, Google said it has also rolled out so-called “Guided Learning” capabilities in classrooms worldwide.
When student accounts look up homework-related topics, Search will not provide direct answers but instead use step-by-step Socratic prompts to guide critical thinking (like breaking down physics formulas or outlining book reports) in what Google says will support “productive struggle.’
Crucial Quote
“This is a particularly clear example of the tech industry going out of its way to force A.I. on us all — even if we have said we don’t want it,” Morgan Polikoff, an education professor at the University of Southern California, told the Times.
Key background
More than 150 million students and teachers rely on Google’s suite of K-12 tools everyday using software like Google Workspace for Education—which provides tools like Docs, Sheets, Drive and Gmail—and Google Classroom, which distributes assignments and organizes course materials. The company exercises near-total dominance over K-12 education, where its low-cost Chromebooks computers represent roughly 60% of all classroom devices. In August, Google turned on AI features as the default option inside its Classroom app for schools in a move that upset some school leaders and parents, who said they felt administrators should be able to decide how and when students used AI. Tuesday’s announcement is a reversal of the August decision but also ties the hands of schools who want their students to have access to Google Search for research.
Big Number
1.4 million. That is roughly the combined student enrollment of the nation’s two largest public school districts, New York City Public Schools and Los Angeles Unified School District, both of which moved earlier this fall to broadly restrict generative AI on district devices. Los Angeles officials specifically said they hoped students could retain standard Google Search while disabling AI Overviews, a compromise Google’s new policy eliminates.
Want to see more Forbes articles on your feed? Tap here to make Forbes Australia a preferred source on Google.
Look back on the week that was with hand-picked articles from Australia and around the world. Sign up to the Forbes Australia newsletter here or become a member here.
