If you didn’t already know who Tim Payne was, chances are, you’re about to. The Wellington Phoenix defender has become an overnight internet sensation after a social media campaign set out to make him the tournament’s biggest star.
Two days ago, Tim Payne was an unheralded 32-year-old defender for the Wellington Phoenix, preparing for a World Cup campaign with New Zealand’s All Whites. His digital footprint matched his low-profile, blue-collar defensive style: a modest 4,700 followers on Instagram.
Almost overnight, Payne has gained more than 1.2 million followers. He is now the most-followed football figure in New Zealand history and commands a larger digital audience than the country’s captain, English Premier League forward Chris Wood, and every professional club in the A-League combined.
So, where is this coming from?
Payne’s rise to fame is not from a freakish highlight reel nor a mega contract to an EPL heavyweight.
He is the latest beneficiary of a highly volatile, algorithmic phenomenon that global sports marketers are struggling to quantify. He has been chosen as the internet’s official underdog.
The campaign began when Valen Scarsini, a prominent Argentine football influencer known on Instagram as El Scarso, decided to locate the least-known player at the 2026 World Cup. Scarsini combed through the official squad lists of all participating nations, filtering for players with minimal social media presence.
It was buried in Group G that he found his muse – a reliable and relatively unheralded veteran with 50 caps to his name.
Scarsini issued a simple directive to his millions of Spanish-speaking followers: create an internet legend.
The campaign went viral with spectacular speed. Within 48 hours, Scarsini’s original videos amassed six million combined views across TikTok and Instagram.The movement gained corporate and cultural scale when Latin music producer Bizarrap amplified the campaign to his 19.4 million followers.
The payoff was staggering. Payne’s Instagram following instantly exploded from a modest 4,700 to more than one million, leaving New Zealand’s top sporting icons and political figures in his digital wake.
He now has a larger audience than New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, and even the official accounts of New Zealand Football and the Wellington Phoenix combined.
It gets better. Payne now has his own anthem with a surprisingly catchy chorus of “no Payne, no gain”. Meanwhile, thousands of fans began uploading photographs of Payne’s official Panini World Cup sticker.
His latest Instagram posts have been flooded with tens of thousands of comments from Latin American fans who have christened themselves “The Payniacs.”
So, how has Payne responded to his newfound fame?
Want to see more Forbes articles on your feed? Tap here to make Forbes Australia a preferred source on Google.
Look back on the week that was with hand-picked articles from Australia and around the world. Sign up to the Forbes Australia newsletter here or become a member here.
