Australia’s biggest companies are 99 years old. Please don’t bolt AI on top

Experts

Westpac turns 209 this year. Nvidia is 33. That gap is the most useful number in the AI debate, and almost nobody is talking about it.
Pedestrians on their phones walk past a Westpac branch sign
Every approval step, policy and system in a 100-year-old company was once a smart answer to a real problem. Image: Getty Images

I lined up the 20 biggest companies on the ASX against the 20 biggest on the Nasdaq. The ASX20 averages 99 years old. The Nasdaq 20 averages 43. We are more than twice as old, and 14 of our 20 are older than the oldest company on their list (Broadcom, at 65).

The shape is different too. The ASX20 has no technology companies. The Nasdaq 20 has 13, nine of which make chips or the machines that make chips. Financials and materials are half of ours, and the financial companies average 147 years. Most of the banks, retailers and telcos in that list earn their living at home.

So when someone says “the Americans are ahead on AI”, they’re right. They’re also comparing a Formula One team with a very respectable ferry.

Age is a feature, until it isn’t

Every approval step, policy and system in a 100-year-old company was once a smart answer to a real problem. That’s the good news. The bad news is that you now own a century of smart answers, and nobody has budgeted for unlearning them.

Fortescue, our youngest genuine startup, was founded in 2003. So were Tesla and Palantir. Same year, very different baggage.

Legacy isn’t just old software. It’s old habits wearing a lanyard.

Sectors set the clock

Banks and insurers operate under heavy regulation, so a cautious pace is a feature, not a flaw. BHP, Rio, Coles and Woolworths run mines, trucks, warehouses and shelves. For them AI shows up as better safety, planning and forecasting, not a chatbot that tidies the inbox.

Different work, different clock. Stop benchmarking a miner against a chip maker.

The layer cake

Here’s the enemy: the layer cake.

Through the 2000s and 2010s we did digital. Then Agile. Now AI. Each time, the reflex was to add: a new team, a new platform, a new ceremony, a new dashboard. Almost never did we remove the old process, the old approval, the old report. Waterfall in a hoodie.

I’m guilty too. I helped create the Atlassian Team Playbook, which is a lot of plays to add and not one to subtract.

Now we’re about to put AI on top of the cake. A fool with a tool is still a fool. You’ve just made them faster. Automate a process nobody should still be running and you’ve built an expensive way of doing the wrong thing at speed. That’s a -1 to 0 on my AI scale, and it’s where most of the activity sits.

So before AI, spring clean. Question WHAT we do. Then question WHY we do it. Only then ask how AI could do it better.

Measure twice, cut once

Being second has an upside. The early adopters overseas have spent the money and made the mistakes in public. Australia can learn from them rather than copy them.

The lesson I’d steal first: the best bets start with the business, not the efficiency. “How many hours did we save?” is a fine footnote. “What can we sell now that we couldn’t last year?” is the question.

Patience here, urgency there

We need both, and the trick is knowing which is which.

Be patient where the stakes are heavy: customer money, safety, regulation, trust. Measure twice there.

Be urgent where the upside is net new: new markets, new products, customers we could never afford to serve. That’s where we stop polishing the crown jewels and start making new ones.

And be honest about where we can actually win. Resources, health, gaming, infrastructure: the ASX20 has world-class companies in all of them. Which of those have a capability the rest of the world would pay for, and are we building on it or just defending it?

Three moves for Monday
  1. Run a “stop doing” audit before any AI pilot. For each process, ask what problem it was built to solve and whether that problem still exists. Deleting a report beats automating it.
  2. Split your AI bets into patient and urgent. Patient ones protect the core. Urgent ones create something new, with a named owner, a budget and a revenue target. Not a committee.
  3. Borrow shamelessly from the first movers. Find three that went early and ask what they’d undo. Then add one measure that isn’t hours saved.

We’ve spent 100 years building what we have. That’s worth protecting. It’s also worth questioning.

So, ASX20 boards, here’s mine for you: what will you take away this quarter, before you add a single thing?


Dom Price is a work futurist, NED and advisor on organisational design, teams and the future of work.

Want to see more Forbes articles on your feed? Tap here to make Forbes Australia a preferred source on Google.

Look back on the week that was with hand-picked articles from Australia and around the world. Sign up to the Forbes Australia newsletter here or become a member here.

More from Forbes Australia

Avatar of Dominic Price - Contributor
Topics: