Meta shareholder sues Mark Zuckerberg and executives over child safety claims

Innovation

Meta shareholder Matt Eisner sued CEO Mark Zuckerberg and a number of other company leaders on Tuesday, claiming they prioritised platform engagement over child safety and presented a misleading narrative that drove the stock up and caused the company to overpay for repurchased shares.
Getty Images
Key Facts

Eisner, whose first lawsuit against Zuckerberg and Meta was dismissed in 2024, sued Zuckerberg and 25 others, including executives and board members, in Northern California federal court Tuesday, claiming the individuals created a public narrative of the company “designed to mask a systemic crisis in user engagement and growth.”

The 656-page shareholder derivative suit, which names Meta Platforms as the nominal defendant, claims that to protect the company’s revenue stream, the defendants made false assurances about child and teen safety and claimed the algorithm was fostering “meaningful interaction” when in reality “it was engineered to reward toxicity for engagement.”

The lawsuit claims Meta’s 2024 annual proxy filing was “materially false and misleading” because it misrepresented and left information out about how Meta is protecting kids on its social media, and the risks it faces from failing to do so.

The lawsuit claims that Instagram head Adam Mosseri, one of the defendants, prioritised “‘clicks’ over child welfare” by deciding to make hiding like counts optional despite research finding that hiding them reduced harmful comparisons, since keeping them would help engagement.

Eisner is alleging that misleading statements caused economic loss and harm to Meta, citing numerous cases including its $17 billion (A$25.2 billion) settlement in August, in addition to $25.63 billion (A$38.1 billion) in repurchased and subsequently retired shares for the nine months ended Sept. 30, 2021, which he alleges Meta overpaid for because the misleading statements drove up the stock price.

The lawsuit is seeking corrective statements from the defendants, and requests that the court block Meta from having a shareholders meeting until those disclosures are presented to the shareholders.

Key Background

Eisner first filed a lawsuit against Meta and Zuckerberg, claiming they misled shareholders in a proxy statement about the company’s ability to protect children on social media. The lawsuit was seeking to block Meta’s 2024 annual meeting until the company amended the proxy statement, in addition to having the company and Zuckerberg cover legal fees and costs, but US. District Judge Charles Breyer in San Francisco dismissed the case, saying the the filing didn’t adequately demonstrate that shareholders suffered economic losses as a result of Meta failing to properly disclose safety risks.

Big Number

$26.26 billion (A$39 billion). The lawsuit alleges that in 2025, the defendants’ false statements drove the stock up and caused Meta to overpay by this amount for repurchased shares.


Want to see more Forbes articles on your feed? Tap here to make Forbes Australia a preferred source on Google.

Look back on the week that was with hand-picked articles from Australia and around the world. Sign up to the Forbes Australia newsletter here or become a member here.

More from Forbes Australia

Avatar of Fiona Riley
Topics: